Successful Students

NEA's Bully Free: It Starts with Me

Partisan Politics Preventing Progress

Dr. John H. Jackson became President of the Schott Foundation for Public Education in 2007, after holding several leadership positions at the NAACP. “Despite the polarized political environment we have today, we can all agree that the current low graduation rate among minority and low income students, and the fact that too many students who do graduate are not college or career ready, is a problem,” Jackson told EducationVotes. The key for us to move forward, he said, is to recognize and set aside the partisan politics that pollute our conversation so we can take on the issues that act as barriers to young people’s learning. Here’s what else he had to say:

You’ve spoken about how partisan politics in the U.S. prevents meaningful progress in education reform. Give us an example of that.

When you look at so many candidates’ education platforms, they aren’t based on solid research as much as they are chosen for what’s politically feasible. Take charter schools, for example. Only 4 percent of American children attend charters, and only 17 percent of those charters outperform traditional public schools, so it just doesn’t add up that so much of the discussion around public education should be about charter schools. Further, the conversations that are anti-union don’t recognize the fact that if unions really were standing in the way of progress, schools in the south where there are very few collective bargaining agreements would be much better, and that’s not the case.

You’ve spoken of the need for systemic change that is supports-based rather than standards-based. Tell us more.

Improving the situation is going to take what I call game-changing policies. While common core standards are a great goal, their implementation is not a game-changer. Look at it this way: For any student who is drowning at school, moving the life preserver further away isn’t going to make them a better swimmer.  Our challenge is to identify the supports that will allow that child to become a better swimmer. The problem is that we’re operating in a political environment in which it’s easier to talk about standards and devise systems that are punitive in nature than to put together a comprehensive plan of supports for teachers to teach and students to learn.

 

Dr. John H. Jackson

What would this comprehensive plan ideally include?

It would have to ensure that every child has access to high quality early childhood education and is reading at grade-level by third grade. And for those students who are not, we have to ask what will impact their learning today. The lack of an agenda in this space is what created an opening for others to say to parents, well, let’s try to get your child this charter school or a voucher, even if there’s no real data to suggest that child will do better there.  For those students who are behind, we’ve got to use a more student-centered approach and provide them with what I call a Personal Opportunity Plan, with additional academic, social, and health supports to ensure that they can catch up and achieve a higher standard.

How can educators help move the conversation in the direction of support-based reforms?

Too often in the U.S., you find elected officials and legislators shaping the profession rather than educators.  The educator community has to offer a portfolio of policy models that work so they are not limited to a defensive posture. It’s very important that we widen the lens on education and see the policies and practices that lead to outcomes we don’t like at the local level.  New Jersey has been moving in the right direction since the state Supreme Court decision that increased equity by requiring additional supports and funding for underfunded districts. They didn’t just plug in more money, they targeted resources for early education and professional development for teachers. As a result, New Jersey is the only state with a significant Black male population with a greater than 65 percent high school graduation rate.

Read the rest of this interview at EducationVotes.com.

View more articles in: Successful Students

1 response to “Partisan Politics Preventing Progress”

  1. Ramon Espinal August 8, 20121:12 pm

    I agree with Dr. Jackson main points. As an elementary school educator, I have seen, in the last twenty years, the impact on families and on the education of their children, of the social-economic challenges they face on a day-to-day basis. When one out five children, in the richest country in the world, are going hungry every day. In that context, nobody can tells me that these social problems aren't major obstacles in accomplishing what the good Dr. is proposing. The fact of the matter is that the partisan politics is definitely a hurdle, but in my view we should not be shy about challenging the Republican educational agenda, which is focused on creating the conditions for privatizing our great American public education system; which is the grater equalizer, and the best antidote to those intractable social-economic hurdles that poor and people of color are facing in their lives.
    Like or dislike? 80

Speak Your Mind

Tell us what you're thinking...and oh, if you want a pic to show with your comment, go get a Gravatar!

Spotlight

Classroom Superheroes

Educators in priority schools are rising to a superhero challenge every single day. Nominate educators in your community and support others at classroomsuperheroes.com

Visit the site »

PSC Superhero Keith G. Pemberton

Keith G. Pemberton is a social worker at Oak Hill Elementary School in High Point, N.C., where he has built a strong and steady pipeline for parental involvement, specifically among fathers and male mentors. Check out his Classroom Superhero profile and leave some words of encouragement.

Visit the site »